剧情介绍
影片中的角色各自面临了困境:身为农村家庭里第一个识字的人,如何才能挤进大学?和每年应届毕业的200万名大学生一起成为找不到工作的「蚁族」,是什么滋味?要是唯一能找到的工作,是卖明知不值钱的文凭给其他人,是否该昧著良心去做?怵目惊心的真实故事,显示在中国,教育可能不再是脱贫的凭借,而是一场巨大的骗局。
In ancient China, education was the only way out of poverty – in recent times it has been the best way. China's economic boom and talk of the merits of hard work have created an expectation that to study is to escape poverty. But these days China's education system only leads to jobs for a few, educating a new generation to unemployment and despair.
In ancient times in China, education was the only way out of poverty; in recent times it has been the best way. China's economic boom and talk of the merits of hard work have created an expectation that to study is to escape poverty. Many Chinese parents see getting a degree as a way of ensuring their children have better, less impoverished lives than their own. But in 1997, the Chinese government privatized universities and education became a commodity. It's a money-making business where there's a profit to be made - The University Entrance Exams Day - the day students receive their results - often determines the future of one's whole life. If you get good results, you get into the state-subsidized universities. If you don't, there are other universities you can get into but they are more costly, often substandard, and run as lucrative businesses. Some unscrupulous colleges employ marketing techniques to target poor, rural families who are often less streetwise to their tactics. More...
陈为军太聪明了,哪怕这种聪明有时候会妨碍到纪录片本身的逻辑,但也很难让人不被这种灵光闪现的敏锐直觉所折服。
非常好,短短一个小时把三类人物都展现了出来。谁是谁的未来,好像是一个圈。残酷二字不愿再提及,小康家庭孩子更应该看的一部纪录片。
揭露骗局的纪录片。很真实。
太真实了,以至于看完后又难受又绝望。剪辑厉害。
高考结束要选大学,大学毕业要找工作,工作后的人寻求解脱
惟有读书高确实是很多农村孩子走出原生贫苦生活的唯一方式,但这一点被传销式民办大学利用后就变味了。努力想摆脱没文化的生活困境,却又因为没文化被骗,这是一个命运的死循环。要读书就要拼了命读,才能靠高考走得出来!
读书确实不是唯一的出路,但是是一条很多人都走过的路,也确实有人走出来了,所以还是努力吧。
“一岁半犯了煞星,猪儿咬人就是残忍。十个手指只留了一个哪。看到别人都把学上,我的心里都羡慕得很哪。也想背个书包上学哪。妈妈哪,听完是眼泪滚哪。说我是什么都不懂,怎么连个事情也看不清,你连一支铅笔都拿不稳,如何可以去读书文”
民办高校就是坑。还有就是少生孩子多种树。
出路——要么足够幸运出身在不愁生存的家庭,要么足够幸运受到很好的教育,而后者往往需要前者作为支撑。可社会只认“优胜劣汰”的规则,剩下的大部分只能被归为既不努力又不优秀的一群人,甚至不能埋怨没有出路,因为是你自己不够努力不够优秀呀,真残酷。
BBC
拍摄于湖北,很多地方都有切身感受。
《 Why Poverty? 》E08陈为军的中国纪录片。”严格的说我们不是学校,是公司,只要把学生弄进来交学费,再发毕业证书把他们弄出去就可以了,其他东西我们都不管。“ 这些人骗的是农村孩子也许卖牛卖羊甚至卖房子的钱,然后坑了青春甚至一辈子。这些人杀人不见血,无耻到了极致!命?8.8
1.困境;2.“这些在城市城村边缘挣扎的年轻人,被人们称作蚁族。”3.“中国有句古话——万般皆下品,惟有读书高”;4.高考毕业生、大学应届毕业生、家长、“传销”似的民办大学招生讲师,让人看见了祖国的希望。
摄影精确得很不像纪录片,人物恰当,好多生活细节选择得极其动人:妈妈的单手,妈妈的歌,女儿和妈妈一样一笑就皱的鼻子,教育学院员工宣讲之后匆匆逃离,刚毕业学生乐观而傻乎乎的气质